Sebbog: 1 revision imported

2023-05-28T15:17:25Z

1 revision imported

← Older revision

Revision as of 15:17, 28 May 2023

wikipedia>Vanisaac: /* Policies, guidelines, essays, and wikiprojects */clean up per WP:CAT#T and WP:AWBREQ add template:Sandbox other and

2020-04-27T04:03:31Z

Policies, guidelines, essays, and wikiprojects: clean up per WP:CAT#T and WP:AWBREQ add template:Sandbox other and <includeonly>

New page

{{Documentation subpage}}


== Usage ==

Use this template to "tag" dubious information or analysis which cites references produced by a [[WP:FRINGE|fringe-theory or pseudo-science]] source, so that other editors can know to back up the statement with reliable citations or remove the claim, per [[Wikipedia:Verifiability]].

It produces a superscripted notation like the following:
:It is evidence of extraterrestrial life.{{Unreliable fringe source}}

Articles tagged with this template will be categorized into [[:Category:All articles lacking reliable references]].

Place this template inline, {{tlx|Unreliable fringe source|date{{=}}{{CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{CURRENTYEAR}} }} following the questionable claim (and any punctuation attached to it). The template should be placed {{em|outside the reference}} (<code><nowiki><ref> ... </ref></nowiki></code>), within the article's text:
:Potentially controversial statement.<code><nowiki><ref>some alleged source for this</ref>{{Unreliable fringe source|date=</nowiki>{{CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{CURRENTYEAR}}}}</code> Next sentence.

=== When to use and not use this template ===
This template should be used to express doubt about the credibility of a source for a claim that is or should be subject to scientific verification.

For [[WP:MEDRS|improperly sourced medical claims]], use the more specific {{tlx|Unreliable medical source}} instead.

This tag should not be used on [[WP:BLPREMOVE|unreliably sourced contentious statements about living persons]]; if the source is not reliable, the statement should be {{strong|removed immediately}}.

For whole articles or article sections that rely on fringe sources, considering using just {{tlx|fringe theories}} or {{tlx|fringe theories|section}}, respectively, rather than individually tagging a large number of statements.

For sources unreliable for reasons other than promotion of fringe ideas, the more general template {{tlx|Unreliable source?}} can be used.

This tag should not be used to indicate that the sourced material could not be found within a given source. In that case, {{tlx|failed verification}} is a better template. For statements that have failed verification {{em|and}} have a questionable would-be source, consider removal of the source (and possibly the statement) over using both tags.

=== Parameters ===

The template has the following optional parameters:
* '''date''': should be set to the month and year when the article was tagged. Example: {{tlx|Unreliable fringe source|date{{=}}{{#time:F Y}}}}
* '''reason''': a note explaining why you think the source is unreliable as per [[WP:FRINGE]] and [[WP:RS]]. Displays as a tool tip. Keep it short (one sentence) as longer material belongs on the talk page. It is good to reiterate the reason in your edit summary. Example: {{tlx|Unreliable fringe source|reason{{=}}{{var|Your WP:FRINGE-based reason here.}}|date{{=}}{{#time:F Y}}}}
* '''sure''' or '''certain''': if set to "y" or "yes" will remove the question mark from the template's output to denote a degree of certainty that the source is unreliable. Please use this with a <code>reason</code> parameter. Example: {{tlx|Unreliable fringe source|sure{{=}}y|reason{{=}}{{var|1=your WP:RS-based reason here.}}|date{{=}}{{#time:F Y}}}}

== See also ==

=== Inline templates ===
* {{tlx|Better source}}, an alternative to {{tlx|Unreliable source|certain{{=}}y}}; especially useful for tagging sources that are low-quality but not necessarily wrong
* {{tlx|Obsolete source}}, for when a source has been surpassed by more recent works
* {{tlx|Unreliable medical source}}, for [[WP:MEDRS|fringe medical]] sources in particular
* {{tlx|Unreliable source?}}, for unreliable but non-fringe sources
* {{tlx|Primary source inline}}, for [[WP:PSTS|misuse of primary source material]]
* {{tlx|Dubious}}, for questionable claims that seem unlikely to be properly sourceable

=== More templates ===
* {{tlx|Fringe theories}}, a banner template for flagging an entire article or section as relying on fringe sources
* {{tlx|Refimprove}}, a banner template for flagging entire article or section as needing better sourcing generally
* [[Wikipedia:Template messages/Cleanup/Verifiability and sources]]
* [[Wikipedia:Template messages/Sources of articles]]

=== Policies, guidelines, essays, and wikiprojects ===
* [[Wikipedia:Verifiability]]
* [[Wikipedia:Citing sources]], especially § [[Wikipedia:Citing sources#Unsourced material|Unsourced material]]
* [[Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources]]
* [[Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources (natural sciences)]]
* {{section link|Wikipedia:Reliable source examples|Physical sciences, mathematics and medicine}}
* [[Wikipedia:Independent sources]]
* [[Wikipedia:Third-party sources]]
* [[Wikipedia:WikiProject Fact and Reference Check]]

{{inline tags}}

<includeonly>{{Sandbox other||

[[Category:Inline citation and verifiability dispute templates]]
}}</includeonly>

Template:Unreliable fringe source/doc - Revision history

Sebbog: 1 revision imported

wikipedia>Vanisaac: /* Policies, guidelines, essays, and wikiprojects */clean up per WP:CAT#T and WP:AWBREQ add template:Sandbox other and